I, Tonya - 9 stars out of 10
“I,
Tonya” is part biopic, part mockumentary, but all quality. This film
humanizes the media-created villainess Tonya Harding and reveals the life that
shaped her polarizing personality. While Harding’s life is a long chain
of sad and unfortunate moments, the film is more of a comedy than a drama with
its tongue-in-cheek tone and over the top acting. One of the film’s most
distinctive features is the incorporation of interviews that are re-enacted by
the cast from interviews filmed by screenwriter Steven Rodgers. They are
the crux of the film’s unique style and provide insight into what the
characters were thinking during their series of unfortunate events. The
interviews also reveal a great deal about Harding as she constantly makes
excuses for her poor decisions. Amidst the comedy, the film makes bold
statements about the cyclical nature of domestic abuse. It drives home
the point that Tonya’s emotionally abusive mother caused her to later accept
physical abuse in her marriage. Some of the most powerful moments in the
film occur when Tonya breaks the fourth wall in a complete emotional disconnect
from the moment because the abuse is so common (and even expected) in her
life. This film is a great showcase for Margot Robbie and Allison Janney,
each one delivering the greatest performance of her lifetime. Janney is
pure evil and one of the most despicable villains that I have ever seen while
Robbie manages to earn our sympathy in spite of her crass and selfish
behavior. She embodies Tonya so perfectly (at age 15 and at age 25) that
videos of the real Tonya won’t look right anymore. Their Oscar
nominations for Actress/Supporting Actress are no surprise and Janney will
likely win hers. By the end of the film, it’s easy to forget how
incredible McKenna Grace was in her brief-but-emotional performance as young
Tonya at the beginning, and Paul Walter Hauser as Shawn Eckhardt is
hysterical. His character is so annoying but you can’t help but get giddy
every time that he appears because he is so blissfully clueless. The
characters are incredibly well-written, though I do have to take issue with one
aspect of the script: The f-word. In fact, 100 of them. I
understand that they are emphasizing the edginess of the characters but it went
way beyond where it needed to be. Even real-life Tonya has mentioned that
she has never sworn as much as the movie indicates. The writers could
have made a great PG-13 film by portraying the rough-around-the-edge
personalities of the characters through a means other than profanity.
Outside of the great acting and storytelling, “I, Tonya” is a well-executed
sports movie. The filming of the ice skating sequences is artistic,
energetic, easy to follow, and convincing that Robbie actually landed a triple
axel. Its Oscar nomination for Best Editing is well-deserved, though it’s
hard to compete with “Dunkirk.” It is important to note that this film
portrays Tonya’s ignorance to the Nancy Kerrigan incident but nobody knows how
deeply she was actually involved. Her character even states that there is
no such thing as truth and this is her version. “I, Tonya” captures an
important moment in American pop culture and fleshes it out to a depth that we
never knew. The story is perfectly cast with characters that you will
love, hate, and love to hate. It is grossly underrepresented at the Oscars
(especially with mediocre movies like “The Post” up for Best Picture) but its
acting and cultural relevance will guarantee it a cult following forever.
[Pictured: This film is all about acting, but the editing of the ice skating sequences is out of this world]